You know when you find out about something, whether it’s an activity, a product, or a TV show, and you think you have it all to yourself? It’s always such a great feeling to think that you’ve discovered something so precious. But then? Everyone finds out about it and all of a sudden…it’s just way too popular. We all know the feeling.

A Reddit user recently asked the internet “What was a great thing ruined by popularity?” And, of course, the responses came flooding in.

Here are 65 things that have been completely ruined by popularity.